Messi scored 50 La Liga goals in 37 appearances in 2011/12. Ronaldo scored 48 in 35 in 2014/15. Messi leads the total by two, while Ronaldo’s 1.371 goals per appearance is slightly above Messi’s 1.351. The comparison covers league matches only.
Try the same number of matches
At 38 appearances, the recorded rates produce 51.35 goals for Messi and 52.11 for Ronaldo. This is multiplication, not a claim that either player would have scored that total. Substitute appearances count as matches, so this adjustment does not equalize minutes.
Keep the two seasons separate
These are different seasons, not a head-to-head race for the same league title. Domestic cups, Champions League matches and internationals are excluded. Our season archive has goals and appearances but no verified minutes field, so the calculator leaves the minute comparison unavailable.